ACCEPTING NEW CLIENTS!

A Decade of Contradictions Part 5 of 5 — The Fourth Child’s Mother: “My Everyday Hero” Private Criticism, Public Praise, and the Question of Deception in Relationships

Woman smiling while video calling family on smartphone at wooden desk.

Apparently, there’s a difference between what gets said in private and what gets posted on social media. Before my son got his own cell phone, my child’s father and I talked about his plans to move to another city or state. During that call, he told me how he met the mother of his fourth child and what he thought about their relationship, her faith, and even their daughter’s name. Weeks later, I saw him post a family portrait with her and share a professional photo of her as a teacher with the caption “my everyday hero.”


The Phone Call Before My Son Got His Own Phone

We were talking about places he might move when I brought up something I’d heard through the grapevine. I’d heard he’d had two more children, bringing the total to seven. Before I could even finish the question, he laughed it off and said something about needing a drink. I hadn’t even gotten to seven yet.


Once I finished asking, he sounded caught off guard. He hesitated, said he didn’t want to talk about it, and told me he was embarrassed and ashamed. He kept referring to her as “the young girl.” She was in her twenties, he was in his thirties, and there were nine years between them.

He told me he met her at Wawa in 2024 and said she wouldn’t leave him alone. He said she wasn’t his type. He told me she went to church, that he’d been baptized there and sang in the choir, and that he thought she was too religious.

He said his family thought she was innocent. He told me she wasn’t and called her crazy. He said he didn’t like their daughter’s name or his first daughter’s name. He described both names as ghetto and said they had too many syllables.

He told me that when he went to jail for child support in 2024, she got his vehicle, went through his phone, and found out he was talking to another woman he really liked. He also told me he didn’t think one of the children looked like him. This was what he chose to tell me during a call that had started with him asking for my opinion about where he might live.

What Showed Up on My Feed

On September 22, the day after our son’s birthday, I noticed that my child’s father had posted a picture of her on his Instagram story. I kept seeing pictures of her each week through about mid-October. A new Facebook page of his also came up in my friend suggestions. We’d had that phone conversation only about a month earlier, so the posts caught my attention.

By mid-October, I saw a photo of three of his children. That same day, I saw a family portrait of him with the mother of his fourth child and his two youngest children, both under a year old. Our son wasn’t pictured in the photos I saw.

Then he shared a professional photo she’d posted of herself as a teacher. He captioned it “my everyday hero.”

“My Everyday Hero”

I laughed when I read the caption. I could still hear him calling her “the young girl” and telling me she was too religious. Within weeks, he was celebrating her publicly.

I joked to myself that even an everyday hero can’t save him from his own child support arrears. If he wants to stay out of jail over missed payments, that’s his responsibility.

I also felt for her. I would have felt humiliated if I’d learned that someone who praised me publicly had spoken about me that way in private. I intentionally hit the love button on the photos. They were beautifully taken, and I was happy at the thought that he might have found someone he could settle down with.


How I Look at Relationship Deception as a Private Investigator

When I look at possible deception in a relationship, I start with the timeline. What did the person say, who did they say it to, and what happened afterward? Here, I had a conversation I could speak to firsthand and a series of posts I saw weeks later. On the phone, he said she wasn’t his type and criticized her faith and their daughter’s name. On social media, he shared a family portrait and called her “my everyday hero.” Each audience got a different picture of the relationship.

The speed of that change made me wonder whether there was an ulterior motive. Had his feelings changed? Had he been telling me what suited the conversation at the time? Or did the praise have something to do with needing someone in his corner while he was down and out?

He kept bringing up her youthfulness, which made me wonder how he viewed the age difference. When someone is going through a rough period, it’s possible for them to lean on a partner’s trust and willingness to help for their own benefit. I don’t know what he told her, what she knew about our conversation, or what either of them expected from the relationship.

What I can say firsthand is how he spoke about her to me and how he presented their relationship publicly a few weeks later. Establishing deception would require knowing more about what he told her and what he led her to believe. The timeline gives me a place to ask those questions.

Maybe he’s found someone again who’s willing to put up with and settle down with him. They say the third time’s the charm, right?!

To be continued…